Best Exterior Paints From Consumer Reports' Tests

At the end of that nine-year test period, many products, like the ones in the list below, still earn a very good rating for appearance. This suggests that they could last an additional three years or longer.

“Consumer Reports’ recommended paints are the only paints we test that will resist cracking, fading, dirt, and mildew after nine years,” says Richard Handel, the test engineer who has overseen CR’s paint tests. Cracking resistance, Handel adds, is the critical attribute for exterior paints and stains because cracks expose a home’s underlying siding or decking to water. Freeze and thaw cycles could potentially cause serious damage.

These formulas are the best from our tests, but this doesn’t mean they’re the only exterior paints in our ratings worth a look. Consider your location: Zones that are sunny, hot, and dry require a paint that resists cracking and fading. Warm, humid areas call for mildew resistance. Desert homes and urban dwellings need paint that resists dirt.

Upgrading your home’s exterior? See our test-based reviews of replacement windows, roofing, siding, and wood stains.

The paints we test cover a wide spectrum of prices, and performance doesn’t necessarily correspond with cost. CR members can read on for our top picks for exterior paint.